Argumentrix is a wiki of claims and rebuttals

Please do not discuss your opinions; no one should know what you believe. Adopt the site's tone and style: simple, blunt, precise, direct, plain, to-the-point. Include only the absolutely necessary context, and eliminate jargon. Content that is convincing, rhetorical, persuasive, elegant, evocative or embellished may be removed.

The Catholic Church is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ

From Argumentrix
Jump to: navigation, search

The Catholic Church is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
Subjects
Apostolic succession
Christianity
Roman Catholic Church
Theology
Linking arguments
Apostolic succession is a valid source of spiritual authority
The Assyrian Church of the East is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
All Christians should belong to the same church
All Christians should be Catholic
The Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
The Bible contains all of the knowledge necessary to attain salvation
Christians should anoint people with oil
Christians should confess their sins to priests
Christian monarchs rule with authority granted by God
Christians can be absolved of sin by confessing them to priests ordained in the Catholic Church
The Eastern Orthodox Church is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
The Greek Orthodox Church of Jerusalem is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
The Greek Orthodox Church of Alexandria is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
The Greek Orthodox Church of Antioch is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
The Moravian Church is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
Only the Catholic Church continues to possess a valid claim of apostolic succession today
The Orthodox Church of Constantinople is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ
The Pope is the spiritually supreme ordained leader in Christendom
Popes of the Catholic Church are part of an unbroken lineage of church leaders going back to St. Peter
Sacred traditions passed down through apostolic succession have equal authority as the Bible
The Syriac Orthodox Church is the descendent of an unbroken line of succession originating in the Christian church founded by the apostles of Jesus Christ


Supporting arguments

The apostolic succession of the Catholic Church is supported by the testimony of Saints Tertullian, Clement of Rome, Ignatius of Antioch, Polycarp of Smyrna, Cyprian of Carthage and Augustine of Hippo. [1] [2]


Saint Irenaeus documented and promulgated the idea of apostolic succession, and claimed that it was possessed by the Catholic Church. [3]


The modern Pope of the Catholic Church has inherited his position in a line that stretches back to St. Peter. [4]

The Biblical Apostles founded a Church which developed into the modern Roman Catholic Church. This line of succession is unbroken. [5]


It can be seen in the New Testament of the Bible that the original church was led by the apostles, and that they passed down their positions to the next bishops as the church developed. This succession developed into the many branches of Christianity today, some of which still possession valid claims to apostolic succession. [6]


Apostolic succession continues today in the Catholic Church and only in the Catholic Church, because that is the only institution that has apostolic roots and has not become schismatic. [7]

Opposing arguments

The Eastern Orthodox Church does not recognize any claims of apostolic validity to churches outside of the Orthodox tradition. [8]


Apostolic succession has had practical value in resolving disputes in church history, but it is not an inherent part of Christianity. Formal legalistic ordination in the modern sense didn't exist in the apostles' times. [9]


Christians should use the Bible and nothing else as their source of spiritual authority, not any claim to apostolic succession. [10]


The Catholic Church formerly gave offices and titles, including bishop to people as political favors, which was an invalid purpose. It is likely that, during this time, the Catholic Church's claim to proper apostolic succession was broken through these invalid ordinations. [11]

The chain of apostolic succession was broken when Pope Sylvester I accepted the Donation of Constantine. [12]

The Catholic Church has demonstrated fallibility and outright dishonesty, which are not features of the true church of Jesus. Thus, it is reasonable to conclude that the chain of apostolic succession has been broken. [13]


The text of the New Testament supports neither the supremacy of Peter nor the succession of his throne into the Catholic Church. [14] [15]


There is no Biblical support for the idea of apostolic succession, which is completely illegitimate. [16]

Notes

  1. Francis J. Beckwith
  2. Michael PS
  3. Dan Petty
  4. Joseph Wilhelm
  5. Robert H. Brom
  6. Francis J. Beckwith
  7. Thomas O'Reilly
  8. OrthodoxWiki
  9. La Vista Church of Christ
  10. Bible.ca
  11. Robin A. Brace
  12. Helmut Reichel
  13. Ex-Catholics for Christ
  14. Constantine
  15. Got Questions Ministries
  16. Got Questions Ministries
Wiki articles by viewpoint
Neutral wikis Wikipedia: Apostolic succession
Citizendium (Academic): None
Debatepedia (Debates): None
Viewpoints Wikinfo (Sympathetic): Apostolic succession
WhyItIsTerrible (Critical): None
Philosophies and topics Atheism Wiki (Atheist): None
FreeThoughtPedia (FreeThought): None
Objectivism Wiki (Objectivist): None
RationalWiki (Skeptic): None
WikiSynergy (Conspiracy theories, inclusive): None
EvoWiki (Evolutionary science): None
LGBT Project (LGBT): None
Religion Wiki (Religious): Apostolic succession
Politics Mises.org (Austro-libertarian): None
Conservapedia (US right-wing, Christian conservative): None
Ameriwiki (US right-wing, Christian conservative): None
dKosopedia (US left-wing): None
LeftSpace (US left-wing): None
Liberapedia (US left-wing): None
Metapedia (Neo-Nazi): None
Christian wikis IronChariots (Biblical, counter-apologetics): None
Christianity Knowledge Base (Christian): None
WikiChristian (Christian): Apostolic succession
A Storehouse of Knowledge (Christian): Apostolic succession
Creation Wiki (Creationist): None
Theopedia (Evangelical Protestant): Apostolic Fathers
OrthodoxWiki (Orthodox Christian): Apostolic succession
Catholic Wiki (Roman Catholic): None
Theologia (Christian, ecumenical): None
Other religious wikis WikiIslam (anti-Islamic): None
Bahaikipedia (Bahá’í): None
Dhamma (Buddhist, Theravada): None
Hindupedia (Hindu): None
Judaism Wiki (Jewish): None
Messianic (Messianic Jewish): None
MuslimWiki (Muslim): None
Wikipagan (Neopagan): None
Scientology (Scientology, independent): None
SikhiWiki (Sikh): None

Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
Toolbox