Argumentrix is a wiki of claims and rebuttals
Please do not discuss your opinions; no one should know what you believe. Adopt the site's tone and style: simple, blunt, precise, direct, plain, to-the-point. Include only the absolutely necessary context, and eliminate jargon. Content that is convincing, rhetorical, persuasive, elegant, evocative or embellished may be removed.
Please do not discuss your opinions; no one should know what you believe. Adopt the site's tone and style: simple, blunt, precise, direct, plain, to-the-point. Include only the absolutely necessary context, and eliminate jargon. Content that is convincing, rhetorical, persuasive, elegant, evocative or embellished may be removed.
In the Eucharist, bread and wine changes into the body and blood of Jesus
From Argumentrix
| In the Eucharist, bread and wine changes into the body and blood of Jesus | |
|---|---|
| Subjects | |
| Christianity |
Eucharist |
| Theology |
|
| Linking arguments | |
| In the Eucharist, bread and wine exists alongside the body and blood of Jesus In the Eucharist, the change of bread and wine into the body and blood of Jesus occurs in a strictly spiritual manner | |
| |
| Wikipedia (Neutral): None | |
| Citizendium (Neutral, academic): None | |
| Debatepedia (Neutral, debates): None | |
| Wikinfo (Sympathetic): None | |
| WhyItIsTerrible (Critical): None | |
| Anarchopedia (Anarchist): None | |
| WikiIslam (anti-Islamic): None | |
| Atheism Wiki (Atheist): None | |
| Mises.org (Austro-libertarian): None | |
| Bahaikipedia (Bahá’í): None | |
| IronChariots (Biblical, counter-apologetics): None | |
| Dhamma (Buddhist, Theravada): None | |
| Christianity Knowledge Base (Christian): None | |
| WikiChristian (Christian): None | |
| A Storehouse of Knowledge (Christian): None | |
| WikiSynergy (Conspiracy theories, inclusive): None | |
| Creation Wiki (Creationist): None | |
| FreeThoughtPedia (FreeThought): None | |
| Theopedia (Evangelical Protestant): None | |
| EvoWiki (Evolutionary science): None | |
| Hindupedia (Hindu): None | |
| Judaism Wiki (Jewish): None | |
| dKosopedia (Left-wing, Americentric): None | |
| LeftSpace (Left-wing, Americentric): None | |
| Liberapedia (Left-wing, Americentric): None | |
| LGBT Project (LGBT): None | |
| Messianic (Messianic Jewish): None | |
| Mormon Wiki (Mormon): None | |
| MuslimWiki (Muslim): None | |
| Metapedia (Neo-Nazi): None | |
| Wikipagan (Neopagan): None | |
| Objectivism Wiki (Objectivist): None | |
| Orthodox (Orthodox Christian): None | |
| Religion Wiki (Religious): None | |
| Conservapedia (Right-wing, Americentric, Christian conservative): None | |
| Ameriwiki (Right-wing, Americentric, Christian conservative): None | |
| Scientology (Scientology, independent): None | |
| SikhiWiki (Sikh): None | |
| RationalWiki (Skeptic): None | |
Bold text
- Note: This belief is called transubstantiation in the Catholic Church and metousiosis in Eastern Orthodox churches.
Supporting arguments
- It is correct Roman Catholic doctrine that the bread and wine substantially changes in the body and blood of Jesus. [1]
- Opponents do not accept the premise that the Roman Catholic Church is a source of scriptural authority.
- John 6:52-56 supports this view. [2]
Opposing arguments
- There is no physical change, but the bread and wine takes on the siginficance of the body and blood of Jesus.
- Supporters do not accept the premise that, in the Eucharist, bread and wine incorporates the significance of the body and blood of Jesus without physicsl change.
- The change is entirely spiritual and does not occur in objective reality. [3]
- Supporters do not accept the premise that, in the Eucharist, the change of bread and wine into the body and blood of Jesus occurs in a strictly spiritual manner.
- There is no change. The Eucharist is a symbol.
- Supporters do not accept the premise that, in the Eucharist, the change of bread and wine into the body and blood of Jesus occurs is entirely symbolic.
Notes
