Argumentrix is a wiki of claims and rebuttals

Please do not discuss your opinions; no one should know what you believe. Adopt the site's tone and style: simple, blunt, precise, direct, plain, to-the-point. Include only the absolutely necessary context, and eliminate jargon. Content that is convincing, rhetorical, persuasive, elegant, evocative or embellished may be removed.

The sacrifice of Jesus allows people to achieve salvation because of the inspiring moral influence that his life, death and resurrection had on humanity

From Argumentrix
Jump to: navigation, search

The sacrifice of Jesus allows people to achieve salvation because of the inspiring moral influence that his life, death and resurrection had on humanity
Subjects
Atonement
Christianity
Jesus
Morality
Salvation
Theology
Linking arguments
All people can achieve salvation because of the martyrdom of Jesus, which satisfies the requisite punishment that would otherwise prevent salvation
The fall of Adam and Eve sent humanity to Satan's clutches, requiring a ransom to redeem them, for which Satan was tricked into accepting Jesus, not knowing that death could not bind him; this freed the souls of mankind and enabled salvation
Jesus recapitulated Adam's circumstances but did not betray God's trust, thereby overturning the stain of Adam's mistake and allowing people to achieve salvation
Jesus avenged the fall of Adam by thwarting Satan, thereby allowing people to overcome sin and achieve salvation
The sacrifice of Jesus allowed people to achieve salvation because he took the punishment that would otherwise be due to them
God allowed Jesus to receive the punishment due to mankind for sin, though Jesus' suffering was disproportionate to the sin for which humanity is responsible; this allowed God to offer salvation while maintaining divine justice


Note: This position is called the moral influence theory

Supporting arguments

Jesus' exemplary life provided a model and inspired humanity to moral self-improvement, thereby enabling salvation [1]

Opposing arguments

Jesus' suffering was a real and substantial replacement for the sins of mankind, despite it being less than the punishment due to humanity. Because of this atonement, God can maintain divine justice while allowing people to achieve salvation through faith and membership in the Christian church. [2]

Jesus actually and really suffered for the sins of humanity, allowing God to maintain his promise to keep divine justice. [3]

When Adam and Eve fell from grace in the Garden of Eden, they sold humanity's souls to Satan. Justice therefore required a ransom. God tricked Satan into accepting Jesus as a ransom, not knowing that Jesus would be resurrected. As a result of this trick, humsnity's souls have been freed so that they can achieve salvation. [4]

Matthew 20:28 supports the view that Jesus died and suffered as a replacement for the punishment due to mankind for their sins. As a result, people who have appropriate faith are able to achieve Christian salvation. [5]

It is taught in the Exposition of Divine Faith, a scriptural work written by Rev. Sun Myung Moon and Hyo Won Eu, that Adam and Eve's betrayal of God's will allowed Satan to gain a superior position, thus resulting in mankind being born in sin and with a tendency to be sinful. Jesus avenged this event, thereby allowing mankind to achieve salvation. [6]

Notes

  1. A. J. Wallace and R. D. Rusk
  2. Hugo Grotius, as described in Wikipedia
  3. Wikipedia
  4. Origen
  5. Harold C. Felder
  6. Frederik Sontag
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
Toolbox